Key Marco Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available in Key Marco and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Newest Listings in Key Marco

$9,750,000

4 Beds ⋅ 6.5 Baths ⋅ 226029366 MLS

Exceptional new construction on prestigious Key Marco, where uncompromising construction, contemporary architecture and sophisticated finishes define this extraordinary three-story residence. Constructed of solid concrete, including the roof, the four-bedroom, five-full and two-half-bath home features impact-rated windows and sliders engineered to withstand winds up to 170 mph, elevated garage and entry levels, 12-foot ceilings and a comprehensive drainage system. A dramatic arrival begins with a circular concrete driveway accented by artificial grass detailing, lush tropical landscaping and preserved native trees. Illuminated steps lead to a 6-by-10-foot glass pivot entry door flanked by towering glass panels. Inside, a backlit decorative tile installation makes a striking statement, while architectural ceiling details, cove lighting and designer fixtures enhance the interiors. A 52-inch circular glass elevator and sculptural staircase with 3.5-inch-thick oak treads and glass railings connect all three levels. Seven-and-a-half-inch oak plank flooring flows throughout, complemented by large-format porcelain tile outdoors. Designed for recreation and guests, the second level features a 17-by-43-foot game room with fully pocketing glass doors opening to the lanai and pool. Three guest suites offer ensuite baths, complemented by an office, powder bath and secondary laundry. The resort-style outdoor setting includes an expansive covered lanai, pool bath and propane-heated pool with spa and sun shelf. The third-floor living and entertaining level is anchored by a bespoke kitchen featuring Poliform cabinetry fabricated in Italy, Dekton countertops, Sub-Zero column refrigerator and freezer, Wolf gas cooktop and ovens, Miele and Fisher & Paykel dishwashers, built-in Miele coffee system, oversized island and walk-in pantry. An adjacent Poliform bar offers Sub-Zero wine storage and refrigeration. The family room features a custom walnut-paneled entertainment center and opens to an expansive covered lanai with wood ceilings and exceptional views. The private owner's suite is a luxurious retreat with a sunset deck, four-person sauna and expansive custom walk-in closet with cabinetry and center island. The spa-inspired bath offers an oversized shower with dual rain heads, Hastings cabinetry, dual sinks, soaking tub and separate water closet with toilet and bidet. Additional features include a custom laundry with Asko appliances and Scotsman ice maker, 43-by-22-foot additional room plumbed for a future bath, whole-house water filtration, dual propane instant hot-water systems and buried 500-gallon propane tank. The four-car garage offers workshop space, epoxy flooring, oversized doors, wiring for air conditioning and an EV charging outlet. An exceptional expression of new-construction luxury, craftsmanship and elevated island living within the exclusive enclave of Key Marco.

1150 Blue Hill Creek DR, Marco Island

$1,250,000

226036285 MLS

Please see the helpful Key Marco information attached to this listing. One of the most undervalued real estate opportunities in Southwest Florida. Incredible, half-acre lot backing up to a large section of Blue Hill Bay/Creek. Gorgeous views of area bays, preserve, colorful sunrises/sunsets out to the city skyline can be found from an elevated home. You cannot find a lot on the Island at this price that offers the opportunity Key Marco does, such as direct access boat slips available, pickleball/tennis, community center with social room/fitness center and more. Key Marco is a prestigious, private and historic gated community where you can escape and get away from it all. From the lot, you are approximately three miles to Publix, area shopping, hardware store, Walgreens and more, and within five miles to Residents' Beach. From the community docks you have direct access to spectacular fishing, adventure and endless sightseeing among the Ten Thousand Islands, Gulf of Mexico and beyond. Great homesite for a new build. (Minimum 3,000 air-conditioned square feet, up to 55 feet high.) Sellers are Florida licensed real estate agents.

870 Whiskey Creek DR, Marco Island

$769,500

226036122 MLS

Please see the helpful Key Marco information attached to this listing. One of the most undervalued real estate opportunities in Southwest Florida. Incredible, nearly half-acre lot with panoramic views of Blue Hill Creek, Blue Hill Bay, colorful sunrises and sunsets out to Barfield Bay and the Marco Island skyline from an elevated home. This is the first homesite of the community, so it is extremely private with only one neighbor and is surrounded by lush, mature vegetation. In the prestigious and historic gated community of Key Marco, where you can escape and get away from it all. From the lot, you are less than three miles to Publix, area shopping, hardware store, Walgreens and more and within five miles to Residents' Beach. Enjoy amenities of the community such as ability to have a direct access boat slip with immediate access to incredible fishing, adventure and endless sightseeing among the 10,000 Islands, Gulf of Mexico and beyond and the recently renovated community center with fitness/social rooms and pickleball/tennis. Great homesite for a new build. (Minimum 3,000 air-conditioned square feet, up to 55 feet high). Sellers are Florida licensed real estate agents.

756 Whiskey Creek DR, Marco Island

$599,000

226036131 MLS

NEWLY PRICED AT $599,000. An exceptional opportunity to build your custom estate in Key Marco, one of Marco Island's most private and distinctive gated waterfront communities. Set on .83 acres along scenic Blue Hill Creek, this homesite offers the space, privacy, and natural beauty that are increasingly difficult to find on Marco Island. Key Marco is an exclusive, low-density island enclave of only 134 homesites, surrounded by lush native vegetation, mangroves, and the waters of Barfield Bay and the Ten Thousand Islands. Designed for those seeking privacy without sacrificing the Marco Island lifestyle, the community combines an extraordinary natural setting with outstanding boating access. For boaters, Key Marco offers a private community marina with direct, bridge-free access toward the Gulf of Mexico and the spectacular waterways of the Ten Thousand Islands. Community amenities also include a clubhouse, fitness center, tennis, and miles of scenic walking and biking opportunities. Imagine designing a custom luxury residence surrounded by tropical vegetation and wildlife, then spending the morning boating, fishing or exploring the Ten Thousand Islands before returning to your private island retreat. Architectural guidelines help maintain the character and quality of this unique community. Despite its secluded atmosphere, Key Marco is only a short drive from Marco Island's renowned beaches, restaurants, shopping, and entertainment. At $599,000, 1011 Blue Hill Creek Drive presents a compelling opportunity to secure a substantial .83-acre waterfront homesite and create your own custom residence within one of Marco Island's most unique gated communities. Bring your architect, bring your builder, and bring your vision.

1011 Blue Hill Creek DR, Marco Island

$195,000

226031751 MLS

For the buyer who wants something different from the typical Marco Island homesite, this is an opportunity to build a one-of-a-kind home surrounded by nature, history, boating and the quiet beauty of Key Marco. Encompassing 546 acres with 375 acres designated as a nature preserve, Key Marco offers spectacular panoramic water views, access to luxury facilities, and unmatched privacy for its residents. This oversized .63-acre homesite offers approximately .30 acres of uplands and .33 acres of wetlands, creating a lush natural setting and buffer around your future custom home. Design a 3000 square foot or larger residence that rises into the landscape, with the potential for up to 55 feet above the first floor grade, subject to applicable approvals, capturing elevated views across serene waterways, native preserve and toward the Gulf. Here, your home will feel immersed in nature rather than surrounded by neighboring rooftops. Key Marco offers lush landscaping and exceptional privacy while remaining just minutes from Marco Island's beaches, dining and everyday conveniences. Owners enjoy access to the community marina with direct (no bridges) boating access to the Gulf, along with clubhouse amenities, fitness facilities, tennis, pickleball, fishing areas and scenic paths. Rich in history, Key Marco has significant archaeological sites documenting thousands of years of human habitation. Gopher tortoises, burrowing owls, roseate spoonbills and abundant native wildlife remain part of the landscape today. Rarely does a Marco Island homesite offer this combination of privacy, natural beauty, boating access and the freedom to create something truly distinctive.

798 Whiskey Creek DR, Marco Island

$2,590,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3.5 Baths ⋅ 226028031 MLS

One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered. Pre-construction opportunity in the gated, premier boating community of Key Marco on Marco Island. Approximately 3,005 SF under air (with an approximate total of 4,301 SF), this coastal estate offers 3 bedrooms, a study, and 3.5 baths, connected by a private elevator. The first-floor primary suite features dual walk-in closets and a spa-inspired bath opening onto a covered lanai, and pool that overlook the tranquil preserve beyond. An open-concept great room, dining area, and kitchen anchor the main living space, complemented by a convenient pool bath and 2-car garage. Upstairs, covered balconies off the landing and the third bedroom offer quiet, elevated perches over the treetops of the adjoining preserve, a peaceful, nature-framed backdrop rarely found this close to the water. This home includes a guaranteed private boat slip at the community marina, with 105 slips across five piers accommodating vessels up to 38', perfectly suited to the Marco Island boating lifestyle. Residents also enjoy Key Marco's private clubhouse, featuring a fitness center, tennis and pickleball courts. One or more photo(s) has been virtually staged, AI generated or rendered.

1065 Blue Hill Creek DR, Marco Island

$6,900,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3.5 Baths ⋅ 2026030763 MLS

Direct Gulf access, a deeded boat dock with electric lift, and unforgettable western sunset views define this custom 2022 waterfront estate on Key Marco's exclusive gated peninsula. Set on approximately 0.63 acres, the property offers exceptional privacy, with protected preserve views and a historic site beside the home limiting neighboring development. The 5,644-square-foot residence combines refined coastal design with thoughtful engineering. Walls of glass frame panoramic water views, while soaring ceilings, hardwood floors, designer tile accents, coffered and tray ceilings, and a private elevator create an elevated living experience. The chef's kitchen features quartz countertops, a six-burner gas range, paneled refrigerator, and a full butler's pantry with a second dishwasher, sink, and extensive storage. A full bar with wine refrigeration makes entertaining effortless. Outdoor living centers on a heated pool and spa, covered lanais, fireplace and fire pit, full outdoor kitchen, and sand bocce court. Boaters enjoy quick access to the Gulf of Mexico from the private dock and lift. Built for coastal confidence, the home features impact-rated windows and doors, a reinforced FEMA-approved panic room, and a basement level with multiple sump-pump systems. The basement floor is approximately 15 feet above sea level, providing valuable storage and exceptional construction rarely found in Southwest Florida. Key Marco provides secluded streets, controlled gated access, preserve surroundings, and convenient access to Marco Island beaches, dining, golf, and shopping. A respected charter school is located just outside the community gate. This is a rare opportunity to own a secure private waterfront sanctuary offering boating, luxury, and some of Marco Island's most spectacular sunsets.

1247 Blue Hill Creek DR, Marco Island

1291 Blue Hill Creek Dr #4, Marco Island

$795,000

226025101 MLS

Unrivaled privacy meets grand-scale potential in this exceptional 1.34-acre homesite, situated within the exclusive, gated enclave of Key Marco. This generously sized parcel offers a rare canvas to curate your ultimate island lifestyle, complete with breathtaking, panoramic views of Barfield Bay. Skip the years of architectural guesswork. The sale of this magnificent property includes the complete plans for a meticulously crafted, one-of-a-kind, stunning, custom-designed elevated estate. Whether lounging by a custom pool or hosting on expansive terraces, the home is engineered to frame this location's extraordinary gulf views. Marco Island's preeminent builder, JP Homes, will build the home for Cost-Plus, or you can hire your own builder. All environmental and archaeological reports are done. Key Marco residents enjoy a newly renovated clubhouse with a fitness center, social room, and catering kitchen, alongside tennis and pickleball courts. Even before building a home, you can enjoy direct Gulf access. Boat-owning lot owners may obtain a boat slip at no cost. The savings from renting a slip elsewhere could more than cover the association fees while your investment in the land grows. Key Marco is the ultra-exclusive destination, and feels like a secluded, private island world of its own, yet you are mere minutes away from Marco Island's acclaimed dining, boutique shopping, vibrant entertainment, and world-famous crescent-shaped luxury beach.

1291 Blue Hill Creek Dr #4, Marco Island

$210,000

226023882 MLS

Build your dream estate in the prestigious gated community of Key Marco, one of Southwest Florida's most exclusive waterfront enclaves. This oversized 0.57-acre homesite offers exceptional privacy surrounded by pristine preserves, mangroves, and breathtaking natural beauty. Located within a 546-acre private island community featuring only 134 homesites, Key Marco provides a rare opportunity to enjoy luxury living in a tranquil, low-density setting. The seller has invested tens of thousands of dollars in professionally prepared building plans and design work, which can be transferred to the buyer—providing significant value, saving time, and helping streamline future construction or expansion plans. Residents enjoy access to a private marina with Gulf access, clubhouse, fitness center, tennis and pickleball courts, scenic walking and biking trails, and some of the finest boating, fishing, kayaking, and wildlife viewing in Southwest Florida. Underground utilities, central water and sewer are available, making this an ideal location to build your custom dream home. Just minutes from Marco Island's world-famous beaches, shopping, dining, and entertainment, this exceptional homesite combines the privacy of a nature preserve with the convenience of island living. Don't miss the opportunity to own a piece of paradise in the highly sought-after Key Marco community.

792 Whiskey Creek DR, Marco Island

$205,999

226024433 MLS

Key Marco very nice gated community, tons of nice upgrades vacant lot, location, location, location, fantastic location to build your dream home, boat slip is included, due diligence before offer, as-is.

816 Whiskey Creek DR, Marco Island

$249,900

226019605 MLS

Steeped in rich history and timeless allure, this extraordinary private island was once home to the ancient Calusa Indians and later the flourishing pineapple plantation of Captain Horr. Today, this exclusive 543-acre gated enclave, featuring nearly 135 homesites, is emerging as one of Southwest Florida’s most coveted destinations for luxury waterfront estates. This exceptional vacant homesite offers the perfect canvas for a magnificent custom residence, where each morning begins with breathtaking sunrises and the tranquility of island living. Residents enjoy a lifestyle defined by natural beauty and refined amenities, including scenic walking and biking paths, winding paved roads, boat slips, marina parking, a community clubhouse, and tennis courts—all within a pet-friendly setting. Ideally located just moments from beaches, dining, boutique shopping, and the esteemed Marco Island Academy, this is a rare opportunity to create a legacy property in a setting unlike any other.

822 Whiskey Creek DR, Marco Island

$1,000,000

225084089 MLS

Discover an extraordinary opportunity to create your custom waterfront retreat on Key Marco, one of Marco Island’s most exclusive and secluded enclaves. This pristine vacant lot offers the rare chance to design and build your dream waterfront residence surrounded by the unspoiled beauty of Southwest Florida’s natural habitat. Set within a private, low-density island community, the property is immersed in lush native vegetation, tranquil waterways, and abundant wildlife—offering a lifestyle defined by serenity, privacy, and connection to nature. Here, mornings begin with gentle breezes and birdsong, while evenings are framed by golden sunsets and the peaceful rhythm of the water. Key Marco is renowned for its quiet elegance and preserved environment, providing a true sense of escape while remaining just minutes from Marco Island’s world-class beaches, dining, shopping, and boating amenities. Whether envisioning a contemporary coastal masterpiece or a timeless island estate, this lot presents a blank canvas for architectural expression in a setting that feels both rare and refined.

1272 Blue Hill Creek DR, Marco Island

Start Your Search

The data relating to real estate for sale on this web site comes in part from the Broker Reciprocity Program (BR Program) of M.L.S. of Naples, Inc. Properties listed with brokerage firms other than this company are marked with the BR Program Icon or the BR House Icon and detailed information about them includes the name of the listing brokers. The properties displayed may not be all the properties available through the BR Program. The information provided is for consumers’ personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any other purpose.